How to Use 5 Whys as a Problem Solving Tool
The 5 Whys technique involves asking "Why?" repeatedly—typically five times—to identify the root cause of a problem. The number five isn’t rigid; the goal is to continue asking until the fundamental issue is revealed. This method, pioneered by Toyota in its production system. The 5 Whys method is widely used in manufacturing due to its straightforward approach and ability to drive continuous improvement.
The process begins by clearly defining the issue, then systematically exploring each answer to uncover deeper insights. This method is particularly valuable in manufacturing, where problems such as equipment downtime, quality defects, and production delays can significantly impact efficiency and costs.
Our Initial Struggles Using 5 Whys
When I first explored the 5 Whys method as a problem solving tool, honestly, I was not a fan of it. When I was an OpEx Manager and a process experienced a failure and we used the 5 Whys, the discussion always ended in "management's" lap.
For example if the initial why question was: "Why did the machine bearing fail prematurely?" Then somewhere along the line of Why questions, the answer became: "Because management doesn't give us enough time for preventative maintenance." or "Management makes us buy cheap parts."
I even had a Lean Leader in another plant tell me that if the root-cause doesn't land on management's shoulders, we weren't doing it correctly. Well this made no sense to me. I was looking for a problem solving tool that would actually solve problems. Not a tool that diagnoses the root cause of every issue as a management issue. You see "Management problem" is not very actionable and it has no place within a continuous improvement culture.
How We Overcame
We really wanted to be able to effectively use the 5 Whys on simple operational issues, because it is much more efficient than some other more complex methods such as FMEA, Fishbone Analysis or the DMIAC process.
Because we really wanted to make sure that we matched the size of the problem to the size of the tool this plant's staff was motivated to make the 5 Whys work for us. As such, I did some research and reflected. What I discovered is that I needed a few ground rules to make this method work.
- The first ground rules was that assigning blame was not an option. This included not blaming management.
- The second ground rule was to work in baby steps through each of the why question levels. Moving from "Why did the bearing fail?" to "Because management made us." seemed a big leap. This new ground rule forced the problem solving teams to think in smaller incremental steps.
- The third ground rule for us, was not to force it. If we get to solid root cause and an actionable solution at why question number 3 or 4, that is just fine!
After installing these three rules, We saw the light and found effectiveness with the 5 Whys method. Using our ground rules, we discover that this method was indeed a simple yet effective technique used to identify the root causes of issues and implement lasting solutions. By repeatedly asking "Why?" our teams could delve beyond surface-level symptoms to uncover the underlying cause of a problem.
The Benefits
This tool's benefits include its simplicity, time-savings, cost-effectiveness, and ability to foster collaboration among team members. For example, it can reveal that equipment downtime stems from missed maintenance, quality defects arise from unclear work instructions, or production delays are caused by outdated inventory systems. By addressing these root causes, manufacturers can improve processes, reduce waste, and enhance productivity.
The 5 Whys approach encourages teams to focus on systems and processes rather than assigning blame, creating a culture of continuous improvement. With its straightforward application and significant impact, the 5 Whys technique is an indispensable tool for solving complex manufacturing problems and driving operational excellence.
How to Use the 5 Whys
- Define the Problem: Clearly state the issue you’re facing.
- Ask "Why?": Identify why the problem occurred.
- Repeat: For each answer, ask "Why?" again.
- Reach the Root Cause: Continue until you find a root cause that, if addressed, will prevent the problem from recurring.
- Implement Solutions: Once the root cause is identified, implement corrective actions to resolve the issue and prevent recurrence.
Examples of the 5 Whys in Action
Example 1: Equipment Downtime
Problem: A key production machine stops unexpectedly.
- Why did the machine stop?
The motor overheated. - Why did the motor overheat?
The cooling system failed. - Why did the cooling system fail?
The coolant pump was not working. - Why was the coolant pump not working?
The pump filter was clogged. - Why was the pump filter clogged?
Regular maintenance was not performed.
Root Cause: Lack of a scheduled maintenance program.
Solution: Implement a preventive maintenance schedule to ensure filters are cleaned and replaced regularly.
Example 2: Quality Defect in Products
Problem: A batch of products fails quality inspection due to incorrect dimensions.
- Why did the products have incorrect dimensions?
The cutting machine was set incorrectly. - Why was the cutting machine set incorrectly?
The operator used the wrong settings. - Why did the operator use the wrong settings?
They misunderstood the job order. - Why did they misunderstand the job order?
The job order was unclear. - Why was the job order unclear?
Standardized work instructions were not in place.
Root Cause: Lack of standardized work instructions.
Solution: Develop and implement clear, standardized work instructions for all operators.
Example 3: Production Delay
Problem: A production line experiences frequent delays.
- Why are there delays on the production line?
Parts are not available when needed. - Why are parts not available?
Deliveries from suppliers are late. - Why are deliveries late?
Orders are placed at the last minute. - Why are orders placed at the last minute?
The inventory system does not provide timely alerts. - Why does the inventory system fail to provide timely alerts?
The system is outdated and lacks automated features.
Root Cause: Outdated inventory management system.
Solution: Upgrade to an automated inventory management system that provides real-time alerts for reordering.
Tips for Effective Use of the 5 Whys
- Be Specific: Clearly define the problem to avoid vague answers.
- Focus on Facts: Base each “Why” on observed data, not assumptions.
- Involve the Right People: Include team members who are familiar with the process or issue.
- Avoid Blame: Focus on processes and systems, not individuals.
- Document the Process: Keep a record of the 5 Whys analysis for future reference and training.
Conclusion
The 5 Whys problem-solving tool is a powerful yet straightforward method for addressing manufacturing challenges. By focusing on root causes rather than symptoms, it helps organizations implement effective solutions that drive long-term improvements. Whether dealing with equipment failures, quality defects, or production delays, the 5 Whys technique provides a structured framework for uncovering the real issues and fostering a culture of continuous improvement.
By mastering this tool, manufacturing teams can not only resolve problems but also prevent them from recurring, leading to increased efficiency, reduced waste, and improved overall performance.
Stay connected with news and updates!
If you want some weekly T4T wisdom coming straight to your inbox for your reading pleasure - look no further! Join our mailing list to receive the latest blogs and updates.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
